CPS prosecutor cited an imaginary case after an AI-generated search summary
Reported by Legal Futures and The Guardian2 sources ↓
A senior CPS prosecutor cited a nonexistent case while arguing that an 11-year-old should face prosecution. The High Court said the citation did not affect the outcome of the boy’s challenge.
Key points
- The fictional case was cited in the CPS’s argument for prosecuting the 11-year-old
- The CPS said an internet legal search caused the error and it carried out an internal review
- A UK tracker of confirmed, suspected and disputed AI-related errors has 101 entries
Sources
Details
Court documents show that Ravinder Dhillon, a senior crown prosecutor, cited a case identified as CPS – R v J [2024] EWCA Crim 3529. It did not exist. The Guardian reports that an AI-generated summary returned during an internet search supplied the fictional case details; Dhillon said she had meant to refer to a different, real decision from 15 years earlier.
The case arose from a challenge by lawyers for a boy who was 11 at the time of the alleged rape of his seven-year-old sister. They argued the CPS had not considered representations from social workers, youth workers and a forensic psychologist before deciding to prosecute. The High Court said the false citation did not affect its decision on the challenge, and the boy’s trial is listed to take place in the youth courts later this week.
The CPS said it identified an error during internet legal research, remedied it and conducted an internal review to check whether other cases were affected. It said its AI policy bars using AI to make legal decisions and requires human accuracy checks; the CPS also said it had shared guidance that case law should be cited from trusted legal sources.
The Guardian reports that a tracker maintained by barrister Matthew Lee lists 101 confirmed, suspected and disputed AI-related errors and related false citations in the UK. In June 2025, the High Court urged the Bar Council and Law Society to consider measures to address AI hallucinations in court proceedings.
Written from coverage as of
Images
- The Guardian