After four years of development, are LLMs capable of writing high-quality prose?
Reported by r/LocalLLaMA1 source ↓
A LocalLLaMA user says years of testing and fine-tuning models have produced mostly generic prose, and asks whether local models can write literary-quality text.
Key points
- The poster says fine-tuning with their own and others’ datasets yielded only mediocre results
- They report similar problems across science fiction, comedy, drama, adventure, romance and historical fiction
- The poster is considering whether LLMs can help write descriptions for 100,000 records
Sources
Details
The LocalLLaMA poster says they have used models from Gemma, Qwen, Mistral, LFM and IBM, along with models built by smaller developers. They report trying QLoRA and full fine-tuning, including runs of up to 100 epochs, but say the resulting prose was only marginally better than output from general models.
The poster says attempts across several fiction genres produced generic writing, and that they now use LLMs mainly to proofread prose they have written themselves. They also question EQBench as a measure of literary quality, and ask whether any local model can generate prose comparable to works such as Dune or The Lord of the Rings.
Written from coverage as of
Stocks in this story
Change since open: 20 Nov to 21 Nov 2026
Last refresh