AI isn't replacing your job. It's turning it into low-paid gig work
Reported by Hacker News1 source ↓
Hacker News reports that AI data platforms recruit workers from physicians to people in lower-income countries for tasks such as reviewing model outputs. Outlier advertises up to $180 an hour for U.S. physicians, compared with up to $7.50 for Tagalog work in the Philippines and $12.50 for Swahili work in Tanzania.
Key points
- Outlier recruits physicians to create cardiac scenarios and review AI-generated reports
- Advertised rates reach $180 an hour in the U.S., versus $7.50 in the Philippines and $12.50 in Tanzania
- Workers interviewed by the author described falling pay and shrinking task times as projects continued
- Scale AI terms allow it to suspend payments during investigations and deactivate accounts without prior notice
- A proposed settlement involving Scale AI has preliminary approval; the company denies wrongdoing
Details
The account describes AI data work as a platform-controlled form of contract labor, in which workers produce examples, evaluations and corrections used to improve AI models. The article says platforms initially attract workers with higher rates, then reduce pay or move projects elsewhere; it recounts a Venezuelan family earning $20 in one day on a labeling task in December 2020 before the task disappeared the following year.
The article says Remotasks ended its hourly program in Venezuela in 2021 and discontinued operations in Kenya, Nigeria and Pakistan in March 2024. Scale AI attributed the closures to enhanced security protocols, but later acknowledged that Kenyan workers had not received advance notices because of operational errors; workers quoted by Rest of World said they were locked out.
The article also describes legal disputes over platform work. Claims by workers on Scale AI platforms led to a proposed settlement that received preliminary approval in San Francisco, while Scale AI denies wrongdoing. A separate class action alleges that Mercor misclassified more than 30,000 lawyers, doctors and engineers while setting their pay and reviewing their work.
Written from coverage as of
Images
- Hacker News