Albanese government warned it’s ‘sleepwalking into another robodebt scenario’ over use of algorithms and AI
Reported by The Guardian1 source ↓
The Centre for Public Integrity says gaps in oversight and transparency around government automated decisions risk repeating failures associated with robodebt. Its report calls for mandatory audits, a public register and an independent oversight body.
Key points
- The report calls for mandatory audits and a public register of government automated decision-making
- It recommends an independent body to monitor, audit and investigate automated decisions
- The report raises concerns about an aged-care assessment algorithm that can under-assess needs
- The government’s automated decision-making framework has no announced publication date
Details
The Centre for Public Integrity’s “Computer Says No” report examines automated decision-making tools used by the federal government and makes eight recommendations. Chief executive Catherine Williams said the centre was concerned people may not know when such tools are used in decisions affecting them.
The report’s concerns include the integrated assessment tool used to determine older Australians’ home-support needs. The Guardian reports the tool has routinely under-assessed needs and package entitlements, while assessors have been barred from overriding incorrect algorithmic decisions. A Commonwealth ombudsman report published in October found recommendations on transparency from the robodebt royal commission had been ignored in the tool’s development and rollout.
The Attorney General’s Department has been developing an automated decision-making framework, following a consultation that ended in January 2025. Attorney General Michelle Rowland did not say when a draft would be completed or made public; she said the framework would include transparency obligations and human oversight. Independent MP Kate Chaney introduced a bill in September to establish a mandatory legislated framework.
Written from coverage as of
Images
- The Guardian