Facial recognition errors put ethnic minorities at risk of wrongful arrest, police watchdog warns
Reported by The Guardian, UA.NEWS, mojkraj.hr and 2 more outlets5 sources ↓
A UK police watchdog found that some officers acted on potential matches from retrospective facial-recognition searches without enough corroborating checks. Its report also cites bias, unsuitable images and custody photos kept beyond their required deletion date.
Key points
- Some investigators treated retrospective facial-recognition results as evidence rather than intelligence requiring further checks
- The report says the system can be more likely to wrongly flag people from ethnic minorities
- Auditors found blurred or unsuitable probe images, including images with multiple faces
- Some custody images that should have been deleted were retained
- The watchdog says there is no comprehensive statutory framework for the technology’s use
Sources
- The GuardianRead ↗Facial recognition errors put ethnic minorities at risk of wrongful arrest, police watchdog warns
- UA.NEWSRead ↗Police inspectorate warns of risk of wrongful arrests due to facial recognition — The Guardian
- mojkraj.hrRead ↗Report: Police treating facial recognition as evidence risks wrongful arrests
- The TelegraphRead ↗Facial recognition cameras risk wrongful arrests, warns watchdog
- The RegisterRead ↗Brit police watchdog says cops' use of facial recog risks wrongful arrests
Details
Inspectors found cases where investigators did not make enough corroborating inquiries before acting on potential matches, and a small number of cases where officers relied too heavily on results and took inappropriate investigative action.
The report says the algorithm can be more likely to wrongly identify people from ethnic minorities. Auditors also found users had submitted blurred or otherwise unsuitable probe images, sometimes containing multiple faces, reducing the reliability of matches.
Inspectors found that some custody images that should have been deleted were still held. The report also says the absence of a comprehensive statutory framework makes it harder for police forces to establish the lawful basis for using retrospective facial recognition and the safeguards required.
Written from coverage as of
Images
- The Guardian