How You Collaborate With AI on Creative Work Makes All the Difference
, updated First seen Updated Limited coverage, tapering
Industry
Reported by CNET1 source ↓
A study of 285 students found that AI sped up creative writing, but how people divided the work affected output quality, creative diversity and satisfaction. Keeping people involved in planning produced better results than having them mainly approve AI work.
Key points
- AI use sped up the writing task but did not improve work quality in any group
- Human Confirmation produced the lowest-quality, least diverse work and lower satisfaction
- Human Creativity and Copilot produced better work at the same speed
- The study involved 285 students completing writing assignments over two days
Details
The study, published Nov. 10 in PNAS Nexus, compared three ways of using AI for writing. In Human Confirmation, AI planned, drafted and edited while people approved each step; in Human Creativity, people planned and outlined while AI wrote and edited; in Copilot, people and AI worked together throughout.
The other two groups produced better work at the same speed. The study found no improvement in writing quality from AI use overall.
Written from coverage as of
Images
- CNET