Ontario Appeal Court Keeps OpenAI Copyright Suit in Canada, Where US Fair Use Does Not Apply
Reported by Turkville and Tech Times2 sources ↓
Ontario’s Court of Appeal dismissed OpenAI’s appeal, allowing five Canadian news organizations to pursue their copyright case in Ontario. The ruling concerns jurisdiction, not whether OpenAI infringed copyright.
Key points
- The case concerns allegations that OpenAI copied news content to train models behind ChatGPT
- The plaintiffs are Torstar, Postmedia, The Globe and Mail, The Canadian Press and CBC/Radio-Canada
- OpenAI must pay $100,000 in costs, according to Broadcast Dialogue; the outlet did not specify a currency
- The court did not decide whether the alleged copying infringed copyright
- Whether relevant copying occurred in Canada remains unresolved
Sources
Details
The unanimous appeal decision, written by Justice B.W. Miller, upheld a 2025 ruling that Ontario courts can hear the publishers’ claims. OpenAI had argued the dispute should be heard in the United States. The appeal court found Ontario had a real and substantial connection to the alleged breaches, according to Broadcast Dialogue.
The publishers allege OpenAI scraped and copied their content to train its models. OpenAI has argued that its training and automated web crawling took place outside Ontario, and that Canadian copyright law does not apply to activity outside Canada. The appeal ruling did not settle where the legally relevant copying occurred or whether the claims are proven.
The Canadian Press reported that the court noted OpenAI had provided no evidence that a Canadian judgment would conflict with U.S. law or complicate enforcement. Broadcast Dialogue reported that the court ordered OpenAI to pay $100,000 in costs but did not specify the currency.
Any defense based on permitted use would be assessed under Canadian law, not the U.S. fair use doctrine. The article says Canada’s fair dealing exception requires a use to fall within a listed purpose, and Canada has no text-and-data-mining exception for AI training.
Written from coverage as of
Stocks in this story
Change since open: 20 Nov to 21 Nov 2026
Last refresh