Schellman CEO: the giant loophole in the White House AI deal
Reported by Fortune1 source ↓
The White House AI accord calls for independent assessments of companies’ safety controls but does not specify who can conduct them or how independence should be verified, Fortune’s Schellman CEO argues.
Key points
- The accord calls on AI developers to monitor risks, set internal controls and use outside assessors
- The accord does not define assessor qualifications, independence requirements or conflict-of-interest rules
- The CEO says assessment reports should disclose their scope, methods, limitations and material findings
- The article cites an AICPA and AIUC offering combining SOC 2 examinations with AIUC-1 certification and quarterly retesting
Details
The accord, released Sept. 29, calls on AI developers to monitor risks, establish internal controls and bring in outside auditors or evaluators to assess those controls. Fortune’s article, written by Schellman CEO Avani Desai, argues that it leaves key terms undefined, including who qualifies as an assessor and how conflicts of interest should be managed.
Desai says this could allow assessments of differing rigor and objectivity to satisfy the same commitment. She argues that assessors should disclose commercial relationships, use defined criteria, explain their methods and undergo independent quality review; reports should state what was examined and what was excluded.
The article says an evaluator also needs sufficient evidence and the freedom to report unfavorable findings. It notes that the accord assigns internal teams responsibility for addressing identified risks and gives an independent board committee oversight of findings and responses, but argues those measures depend on assessors being able to report concerns without pressure.
Desai points to a joint AICPA and AIUC offering that pairs SOC 2 examinations with AIUC-1 certification and quarterly retesting of AI agents. She says stronger methods alone are not enough and calls for clear assessor qualifications and oversight, while keeping assurance practical for smaller developers.
Written from coverage as of
Images
- Fortune