Should AI be judging our credit worthiness?
Reported by BBC News1 source ↓
AI-based lending tools could help assess borrowers with limited credit histories, but experts warn they may reproduce past discrimination and say consumers need ways to understand and challenge decisions.
Key points
- Upstart and Zest AI offer lenders machine-learning tools to assess creditworthiness
- Thin-file applicants, including young people and recent immigrants, can be disadvantaged by traditional scoring
- Experts warn AI may reproduce bias and call for safeguards and ways to challenge errors
- UK credit agency Noggin HQ uses bank transaction data to assess applicants without AI
Details
In the US, firms including Upstart and Zest AI offer lenders machine-learning tools as an alternative or addition to traditional credit scoring. Upstart says its models examine more than 2,500 variables. Mortgage expert Sarah Tucker says broader data analysis could help lenders form a more individual view of affordability, including for people with little credit history.
Experts also warn that AI systems could carry forward inequalities reflected in past decisions. Oxford professor Sandra Wachter says lenders must establish accountability and safeguards, while Tucker says consumers should know what information is used and be able to challenge incorrect decisions. Upstart says it evaluates its models for bias as part of training.
Traditional credit scoring can leave people with limited credit histories at a disadvantage. The BBC reports that Brighton resident Hope discovered identity fraud had damaged her score after a mortgage application was denied; Evangeline Atkinson says she was refused a phone contract because credit agencies had no record of her.
Atkinson founded UK credit reference agency Noggin HQ, which the BBC says was authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority in June. It helps lenders analyse applicants’ current-account transaction data without using AI. The article also reports that Experian partnered with OpenAI in August 2026 to let users check credit scores in ChatGPT, while Equifax and TransUnion have announced AI-related initiatives.
Written from coverage as of
Images
- BBC News
- BBC News
- BBC News
- BBC News
Stocks in this story
Change since open: 20 Nov to 21 Nov 2026
Last refresh