Science finds wearable EEG firms collected brain data without clearly disclosing AI training
Reported by Tom's Hardware, news.lavx.hu and Gadget Review3 sources ↓
A Science investigation found that wearable neurotechnology companies collected EEG recordings and some used them to train AI models without clearly disclosing that use to customers. Interaxon and Emotiv updated their privacy policies after questions from the investigation.
Key points
- Interaxon says it trained an AI model on about 50,000 hours of EEG recordings, mostly from device users
- Interaxon says it removes direct identifiers before using recordings for model development
- Emotiv disclosed model training on de-identified data subject to opt-in consent
- The investigation found no clear prior disclosure among the nine companies it identified as building brain foundation models
Sources
- Tom's HardwareRead ↗Wearable sleep trackers are using your brainwaves to train AI models without explicit user consent
- news.lavx.huRead ↗Sleep tracker makers harvest tens of millions of hours of brainwave data to train AI models
- Gadget ReviewRead ↗Your Sleep Tracker Has Been Using Your Brain Waves To Train AI Without Telling You
Details
Science’s investigation, conducted with the Pulitzer Center’s AI Accountability Network, reviewed consumer neurotechnology companies’ data practices. It found that companies had collected tens of millions of hours of EEG recordings, but that total is not a verified count of recordings used to train AI models. The investigation identified nine companies that had publicly said they were developing brain foundation models.
Interaxon told Science it trained an AI model on about 50,000 hours of EEG recordings, most collected from its Muse device users, and said it removes direct identifiers before use. Its privacy policy did not explicitly disclose model training before the investigation’s questions; the company later updated it. Emotiv also updated its policy to disclose use of de-identified neural data for training, subject to opt-in consent.
The investigation found that more than two-thirds of the companies studied allowed corporate transfers of neural data without user consent. Colorado and California have amended consumer privacy laws to cover neural data, while other states have not adopted similar protections. Gadget Review reports that Emotiv’s terms say withdrawing consent stops future data ingestion but does not remove contributions already incorporated into trained model weights; it says equivalent confirmation was not available for Interaxon.
Written from coverage as of
Images
- Tom's Hardware
- news.lavx.hu
- Gadget Review